The bending machine: CO2 activation and hydrogenation on d-MoC(001) and b-Mo2C(001) surfaces

The adsorption and activation of a CO2 molecule on cubic d-MoC(001) and orthorhombic b-Mo2C(001) surfaces have been investigated by means of periodic density functional theory based calculations using the Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof exchange–correlation functional and explicitly accounting for (or neglecting) the dispersive force term description as proposed by Grimme. The DFT results indicate that an orthorhombic b-Mo2C(001) Mo-terminated polar surface provokes the spontaneous cleavage of a C–O bond in CO2 and carbon monoxide formation, whereas on a b-Mo2C(001) C-terminated polar surface or on a d-MoC(001) nonpolar surface the CO2 molecule is activated yet the C–O bond prevails. Experimental tests showed that Mo-terminated b-Mo2C(001) easily adsorbs and decomposes the CO2 molecule. This surface is an active catalyst for the hydrogenation of CO2 to methanol and methane. Although MoC does not dissociate C–O bonds on its own, it binds CO2 better than transition metal surfaces and is an active and selective catalyst for the CO2 + 3H2 CH3OH + H2O reaction. Our theoretical and experimental results illustrate the tremendous impact that the carbon/metal ratio has on the chemical and catalytic properties of molybdenum carbides. This ratio must be taken into consideration when designing catalysts for the activation and conversion of CO2.


Introduction
Carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) is the most abundant greenhouse gas in Earth's atmosphere owing mostly to vast emissions derived from human activities.2][3][4] The recovery of CO 2 for its hydrogenation to alcohols or other hydrocarbon compounds is an important approach to recycle the released carbon dioxide. 4However, for these reactions to occur, the chemical activation of the CO 2 molecule is a necessary and oftentimes crucial step, which typically implies charge transfer from the catalyst and the molecular bending. 5ost of the catalysts used in the industry for the abovementioned reactions use metal nanoparticles such as Ni, Pd, or Pt as an active phase that are supported either on oxides or fine sulfides. 6Due to their complexity and cost, experiments are typically performed using model supported nanoparticles. 7In the current search for new catalysts, 8 Transition Metal Carbides (TMCs) have arisen as appealing alternatives, because they exhibit broad and amazing physical and chemical properties. 9hese may be viewed as the result of combined properties of covalent solids, ionic crystals, and transition metals. 10Because of these properties and their low cost, TMCs have become a type of materials with an increasing role in heterogeneous catalysis in the last few decades, either using them as catalysts or as supports for metal nanoparticles.The pioneering work of Levy and Boudart indicated that tungsten carbide showed catalytic activity very similar to or even better than platinum, for a variety of reactions. 11Since then, the number of reactions catalyzed by TMCs has greatly increased.Beyond the catalytic activity per se, another very important application that has been contemplated is the ability to use TMCs as supports for metal nanoparticles.][14][15][16] Also, TiC(001) and Au-TiC(001) systems have been found to catalyze H 2 dissociation 17,18 and CO oxidation. 19In the latter, the attachment strength of CO on the TiC(001) surface or Au clusters is not very different, 20 but O 2 adsorption energy is higher on the Au-TiC(001) system.
It should be borne in mind that titanium carbide is a cumbersome support to be used in applications due to the difficulty in obtaining nanoparticles under working conditions.It is therefore better to work with d-MoC and b-Mo 2 C because they are much more active and do not require special conditions for their synthesis.Molybdenum carbides have been used as catalysts in different reactions: The orthorhombic b-Mo 2 C has been proposed as a possible substitute to the commercial Cu-based catalyst used to carry out the Water-Gas-Shift (WGS) reaction 21,22 and also as a highly beneficial support to Pt nanoparticles in the catalyzed WGS reaction. 23oreover, b-Mo 2 C has been recently found to be not only a good support to Ni nanoparticles, but also an active phase to the so-called Ni/b-Mo 2 C bifunctional catalyst used in the methane dry reforming process.The catalytic activity of these systems has been previously predicted based on Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations 24,25 and, very recently, has become the focus of a detailed mechanistic study. 26Furthermore, it has been predicted that d-MoC(001) can easily dissociate molecular oxygen 27 and DFT calculations showed the very high catalytic power of hexagonal a-Mo 2 C on ammonia dehydrogenation. 28lso, hexagonal a-Mo 2 C(001) and orthorhombic b-Mo 2 C phases have been considered as catalysts for CO hydrogenation, [29][30][31] and very recently, b-Mo 2 C(001) has been proposed for CO dissociation. 32he objective here is to explore and determine whether the CO 2 molecule adsorbs on the (001) surfaces of d-MoC and b-Mo 2 C and see if activation of CO 2 occurs, as a first, preliminary, and necessary step for using molybdenum carbides as catalysts in CO 2 chemistry.An important issue is to determine how the activity towards CO 2 activation changes with the carbon/metal ratio in the carbide.It will be shown that CO 2 gets activated on d-MoC(001) and the C-terminated b-Mo 2 C(001), whereas an almost barrierless dissociation occurs on Mo-terminated b-Mo 2 C(001), pointing to these surfaces as ideal active phases of molybdenum carbide composites for CO 2 activation.Indeed, experimental tests show that Mo-terminated b-Mo 2 C(001) easily adsorbs and decomposes the CO 2 molecule.It is shown that this surface is also an active catalyst for the hydrogenation of CO 2 to methanol and methane.

A. Computational details
Periodic density functional calculations were carried out using the Vienna Ab initio Simulation Package (VASP) 33 for the slab surface models depicted in Fig. 1.Exchange-correlation effects have been accounted for by means of the generalized gradient approximation using the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) exchangecorrelation (xc) functional, 34 given the suitability of such an xc functional for the description of bulk and surfaces of molybdenum carbide compounds. 35The van der Waals (vdW) correction proposed by Grimme 36 has been used to test the difference between the uncorrected calculations and calculations with vdW correction.In these calculations the valence electron density is expanded in a plane-wave basis set and the effect caused by the core electrons on the valence region is described by the projector augmented wave method of Blo ¨chl 37 as implemented by Kresse and Joubert. 38The kinetic energy cut-off for the plane wave basis set was set to 415 eV, proven to be enough to gain converged results for adsorbates on carbides in general, and in molybdenum carbides in particular. 35The ionic relaxation convergence criterion was adjusted so that all forces acting on atoms were always smaller than 0.01 eV Å À1 .The electronic relaxation was considered converged when the total energy in subsequent iterations varied less than 10 À5 eV.The slab models of the surface of interest contain four atomic layers, two of them previously relaxed, i.e. the (2 + 2) approach.In the case of cubic d-MoC(001) this approach leads to a sufficiently thick slab as demonstrated in several previous studies. 27,39,40However, in the case of the Mo-terminated b-Mo 2 C(001) one may wonder if the smaller interlayer distance results in a more limited representation of the surface even if previous work on the properties of the naked surfaces strongly suggests that this choice is adequate. 35To further confirm that this is the case for the predicted properties of adsorbed species, key calculations have been repeated with a slab model containing six atomic layers with the four topmost relaxed and the two bottom ones fixed as in the bulk.The calculated results with the 4 and 6 layer models exhibit very small variations as commented in the next section.For any of the studied surfaces a (2 Â 2) supercell was employed.All supercells contain 32 atoms of Molybdenum.Cubic d-MoC(001) also contains 32 Carbon atoms and orthorhombic b-Mo 2 C contains 16 atoms of Carbon.The cell dimensions are 8.75 Â 8.75 Â 18.75 Å for d-MoC(001) and 12.12 Â 10.46 Â 14.75 Å for b-Mo 2 C (12.12 Â 10.46 Â 17.75 Å for the larger (4 + 2) slab model). 35The vacuum space is superior to 10 Å in all cases.
CO 2 was adsorbed on one side of the slab, and during the course of the geometry optimization the CO 2 molecule as well as topmost two layers were fully relaxed.The reciprocal space was described by means of a 3 Â 3 Â 1 Monkhorst-Pack 41 scheme for the d-MoC(001) nonpolar surface and a 5 Â 5 Â 1 grid for polar b-Mo 2 C(001) surfaces.We show the different endings in Fig. 1.For b-Mo 2 C(001) polar surfaces a counterdipole was placed in the middle of the vacuum region to avoid dipole coupling between repeated slabs.For d-MoC(001) this correction is not necessarily included in the calculations because the variation of adsorption energy values (E ads ) is negligible (0.05 eV at most).The adsorption energy is calculated according to the following formula: where coordination contacts through molecule C or O atoms.Final adsorption optimized structures have been characterized as minima in the potential energy surface via appropriate frequency analysis.This was carried out using the Hessian matrix constructed from finite differences of analytical gradients with individual displacements of 0.03 Å in each cell direction and including both molecule atoms and those of the first layer of the carbide in the calculations.Diagonalization of the Hessian matrix thus obtained leads to positive eigenvalues only.

B. Experimental details
Experiments were carried out to investigate the adsorption and hydrogenation of CO 2 on polycrystalline MoC and on a Moterminated Mo 2 C(001) surface. 42Ion bombardment and subsequent annealing at 1000 K were used to clean and prepare the Mo 2 C(001) surface. 43Images of scanning tunneling microscopy indicate that under these conditions this surface has the expected bulk-terminated (1 Â 1) orthorhombic periodicity, 43 with two or three rotationally misaligned orthorhombic domains.The surface of MoC examined in this study is best described as polycrystalline. 42Surface impurities were removed by Ar + sputtering, and a C/Mo ratio close to 1 was restored by exposing this surface to C 2 H 2 or C 2 H 4 at 800-900 K. 42 Several attempts were made to prepare well-defined surfaces of d-MoC oriented along the (001) plane of this carbide.However, it was not possible to prepare an ideal d-MoC(001) surface.The preparation of this particular surface is very difficult due to the complex phase diagram of MoC. 44he experimental data were collected in a set-up that combined an ultra-high vacuum (UHV) chamber for surface characterization and a micro-reactor for catalytic tests. 45The UHV chamber was equipped with instrumentation for X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), low-energy electron diffraction (LEED), ion-scattering spectroscopy (ISS), and thermal-desorption mass spectroscopy (TDS). 45In the studies of CO 2 hydrogenation, the sample was transferred to the reactor at B300 K, then the reactant gases, 0.049 MPa (0.5 atm) of CO 2 and 0.441 MPa (4.5 atm) of H 2 , were introduced and the sample was rapidly heated to the reaction temperature (500, 525, 550, 575, and 600 K).Product yields were analyzed by a gas chromatograph. 46,47In our experiments data were collected at intervals of 15 min up to a total reaction time of 270 min.The amount of molecules (CO, CH 4 , or CH 3 OH) produced in the catalytic tests was normalized by the active area exposed by the sample and the total reaction time.The kinetic experiments were done in the limit of low conversion (o5%).

A. Theoretical studies
First of all we determined the CO 2 molecule orientation upon adsorption.To this end different starting structures were considered.In the perpendicular to surface orientation, one oxygen interacts with the studied surfaces whereas in the parallel to surface orientation all CO 2 atoms are in contact with the surface.The calculations indicate that the parallel adsorption of CO 2 is much more favorable than the perpendicular adsorption by at least 0.5 eV.Consequently, in the following, only the results for parallel adsorption are discussed.
All adsorption sites on the d-MoC(001) surface were studied and the results are summarized in Table 1.It is shown that the CO 2 molecule can adsorb in two competitive sites (see Fig. 3).In the first one, the C atom is above the MMC site and O atoms are on top of Mo surface atoms resulting in an adsorption energy value of À0.82 eV; in addition, upon adsorption the molecule forms one regular C-C bond (1.46 Å) with the surface C. In the second case, the C atom is on top of a surface C atom and O atoms bridge C-Mo surface bonds; the corresponding E ads is À0.74 eV and the adsorbed molecule also forms a regular C-C bond (1.47 Å) with the surface C atom.In both cases the chemisorption of CO 2 leads to elongation of the C-O bonds from 1.17 Å as in vacuum calculations to 1.29 Å in the adsorbed molecule, highlighting the molecular activation.Note that the C-C bond length lies between a single and a double bond.Last but not least, the adsorption is accompanied by bending of the molecular angle reaching values in the 120-1301 range.These structural changes are in perfect agreement with substratemolecule charge transfer, which reduces the CO 2 bond order, although the bending can be viewed as well as a change in spsp 2 hybridization forced by the C-C bond formation.From the vdW values listed in Table 1 one sees that the geometries of these systems do not vary, and only adsorption strengths are increased, revealing that dispersive forces do not play a role in CO 2 activation.Although the preferential site for PBE and PBE-vdW is different,  one can still assure that the CO 2 adsorption on d-MoC(001) presents two competitive adsorption sites.
In previous studies examining the interaction of CO and CO 2 on TiC(001) 20,45 it was found that adsorption resulted in the formation of a new C-C bond between the surface and the adsorbate.For adsorbed CO, the C-C bond length was found to be 1.33 Å, whereas in the CO 2 -TiC(001) system and in the present CO 2 -d-MoC(001) systems the C-C bond distance is sensibly larger.The bending of the CO 2 molecule on TiC(001) was found to be indicative of a net carbide-CO 2 charge transfer. 48For the present studied systems the charge distribution is estimated by the method of Bader, 49 and the results are shown in Table 1.By analyzing these results one observes that for the activation of CO 2 on d-MoC(001) there is also a net carbide-CO 2 charge transfer of B1 electron.In CO 2 /TiC(001) the elongation of the C-O bonds is the same as that in the CO 2 /d-MoC(001) adsorption system.On the other hand, the adsorption energy of CO 2 /TiC(001) is À0.62 eV, so the CO 2 molecule adsorbs sensibly stronger on the d-MoC(001) surface.Thus, the longer C-C bond length in d-MoC can be easily attributed to the size of Mo atoms compared to Ti atoms in TiC, and the concomitant increased steric repulsion.As we will discuss below, the differences in the strength of the CO 2 -carbide binding when going from TiC to MoC probably help to make MoC a better catalyst for CO 2 hydrogenation than TiC.
The experimental results included later on are for Moterminated b-Mo 2 C(001) but it is relevant to study the corresponding C-terminated surface as well.Hence, in a subsequent step, we investigated the interaction of CO 2 with these two b-Mo 2 C(001) polar surfaces.The results (Table 1) show that the adsorption energy is À0.Here one may wonder whether this dissociation is realistic or an artifact of the optimization procedure.To further verify that this is indeed the physically meaningful dissociation pathway, a CO 2 adsorption energy profile has been constructed in a stepwise fashion optimizing points where the height of the C atom of the molecule was kept fixed and the transition state (TS) structure found from appropriate refinement of the energy maximum structure in the potential energy section in Fig. 5, followed by a characterization by frequency analysis, as carried out for the adsorption minima.The Hessian matrix displays only one negative eigenvalue corresponding to the imaginary frequency of the dissociation mode.It can be observed that at a distance of 2.75 Å a minimum energy is found with an adsorption energy of B0.2 eV, i.e. corresponding to a physisorption situation whereas at higher distances the CO 2 molecule does not feel the surface.The TS structure obtained involves a distance from the C atom to the surface of 2.30 Å, displaying C-O distances of 1.22-1.23Å, significantly larger than the 1.17 Å C-O distance for the gas phase molecule, an O-C-O angle of 1451 and involves an energy barrier of 0.76 eV.This energy barrier is larger than the physisorption energy but small enough so that it can be overcome at high coverage under realistic reaction conditions (see next section).Once the energy barrier is overcome, the reaction proceeds through a downhill path associated with a C-O bond cleavage reaching a minimum with a C-surface distance of 1.35 Å.It is worth stressing that such low activation barrier dissociations are not seldom, and have been previously observed for SO 2 dissociation on b-Mo 2 C(001). 15The Bader analysis shows that the CO moiety has gained B1 electron, so it can be considered as a carbonyl anion (CO À ), whereas the O moiety This journal is © the Owner Societies 2014 has gained B2 electrons, indicating that this moiety can be considered an oxygen anion (O 2À ).Note that the structure of the CO moiety matches that of a recent similar study considering the CO adsorption and dissociation on b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo, studied using DFT at the PBE level. 32n the latter study the dissociation of CO was found to be exothermic, yet overcoming an energy barrier of more than 1 eV.This goes for a range of low temperatures in which CO 2 can be dissociated, yet the formed CO molecules can be stable at the surface.As we will see in the experiments described below, CO 2 does dissociate on the b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo surface to yield O and CO which could undergo further decomposition.The CO and C produced by the partial and total decomposition of CO 2 can be catalytically hydrogenated to form methanol and methane.Note that in a CO 2 -b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo system, and according to the energy profile depicted in Fig. 5, the molecules will reach a physisorbed state, from which a fraction can be desorbed and the other can overcome a rather small dissociation energy barrier to reach the stationary point where CO and O moieties are present at the b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo surface.

B. Experimental studies
The O 1s region in XPS was used to investigate the adsorption of CO 2 on polycrystalline MoC and on a b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo surface at 300 K.The interaction of CO 2 with polycrystalline MoC was weak and a very small and broad peak was seen by XPS at O 1s binding energies between 531 and 533 eV.This binding energy can be attributed to the presence of CO or CO 2 species on the surface. 50ince no signal was seen in the binding energy range of 528-530 eV where surface atomic O is expected, 51 it is likely that the weak features seen at 531-533 eV correspond to adsorbed CO 2 .Since our MoC surface is probably rich in carbon, a direct comparison with the theoretical results for the well-defined d-MoC(001) surface is not possible.For the adsorption of CO 2 on the b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo surface, XPS showed two separate features in the O 1s region.The first one peaked at 529.8-530.2can be attributed to atomic oxygen. 51The second one exhibited its maximum intensity at 531.2-531.5 eV and corresponds to adsorbed CO. 51 1. Fig. 7 displays the uptake of CO and O on b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo after several doses of CO 2 at 300 K.The amount of O present on the surface is always larger than that of CO.Since CO binds well to similar surfaces of Mo 2 C, 51 our results imply that two decomposition reactions are taking place on the carbide surface: CO 2 -CO + O; CO -C + O.This is particularly the case at low coverages when the concentration of O is more than double the concentration of CO.Once the adsorbate coverage increases on the surface, the full decomposition of CO 2 becomes more difficult and the ratio of surface O/CO decreases.
In the area of green chemistry, the activation of CO 2 and its hydrogenation to alcohols or other hydrocarbon compounds is an important approach to recycle carbon dioxide. 4This sequence of steps is not fast at 500 K and MoC cannot compete with b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo as a catalyst for methanol synthesis.However, the high reactivity of b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo towards CO 32,51 can be problematic at very high temperatures.In Fig. 8, the rate for methanol production on b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo at 600 K is somewhat smaller than that at 500 K.  On polycrystalline MoC, the hydrogenation of CO 2 produced only CO and CH 3 OH.Fig. 10 shows Arrhenius plots for the generation of CO and methanol on MoC.MoC exhibits a catalytic activity higher than that of Cu(111), 47 a surface that is commonly used as a benchmark in catalytic studies, 46,47 and a TiC(001) catalyst. 45From the Arrhenius plot in Fig. 10, one can estimate an apparent activation energy of 17.2 kcal mol À1 for the synthesis of methanol from CO 2 hydrogenation on MoC.This value is smaller than the corresponding values of 20.9 and 25.4 kcal mol À1 found on TiC(001) and Cu(111), respectively. 45,47n the catalytic process the initial step of binding the CO 2 molecule is important because the sequence in the magnitude of the calculated CO 2 adsorption energies (Cu 47 { TiC 45 o MoC) matches well the sequence found for the catalytic activity.Furthermore, the results in Fig. 8 and 10 indicate that MoC is a   good and selective catalyst for methanol synthesis at high temperatures.When going from Mo 2 C to MoC, the increase in the carbon content of the carbide moderates the reactivity of the Mo centers which still can bind well the CO 2 molecule but now the cleavage of the first C-O bond must be assisted by hydrogen (H + OCO -HOCO -HO + CO) 52 and there is no rupture of the second C-O bond.As a result of this property, MoC is a selective catalyst for a CO 2 -CH 3 OH transformation.The theoretical results in Table 1 and the experimental data in Fig. 9 and 10 illustrate the tremendous impact that the carbon/metal ratio on the chemical and catalytic properties of molybdenum carbides.This ratio must be taken into consideration when designing catalysts for the activation and conversion of CO 2 .

Conclusions
Periodic DFT calculations and experiments on controlled conditions have been carried out to investigate CO 2 adsorption and subsequent hydrogenation on MoC and Mo 2 C surfaces.The DFT calculations have been carried out using the PBE functional and explicitly accounting for a description of vdW forces.
The study also addresses to determine whether there are differences in the reactivity of both b-Mo 2 C(001) terminations, depending on whether the layer that interacts with the CO 2 is built up of C or Mo atoms.Results show that the vdW correction provides no structural differences in the optimized structures.Therefore, these forces are not decisive in CO 2 adsorption and activation.Furthermore, it is found that the CO The predictions from the DFT calculations were confirmed by experimental tests which showed that Mo-terminated b-Mo 2 C(001) easily adsorbs and decomposes the CO 2 molecule.Moreover, there is clear experimental evidence that this surface is an active catalyst for the hydrogenation of CO 2 to methanol and methane.The experiments also show that MoC binds and activates CO 2 better than transition metal surfaces and that it is an active and selective catalyst for the CO 2 + 3H 2 -CH 3 OH + H 2 O reaction.
The theoretical calculations also indicate that there are very large differences in reactivity between the two b-Mo 2 C(001) endings and are in agreement with the experimental evidence of CO 2 breaking on the b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo terminated surface.All in all, the present results show the high activity of molybdenum carbide surfaces in CO 2 activation, surpassing even that of other transition metal carbide surfaces such as TiC(001).Moreover, the present combined theoretical and experimental study illustrates the tremendous impact that the carbon/metal ratio has on the chemical and catalytic properties of molybdenum carbide surfaces.This ratio must be taken into consideration when designing catalysts for the activation and conversion of CO 2 .

Fig. 1
Fig. 1 Sketches of the studied surfaces: The d-MoC(001) (left), b-Mo 2 C(001)-C (middle), and b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo (right).Surfaces are shown by (a) side view and (b) top view.Blue and orange balls denote Mo and C atoms, respectively.The two layers that are relaxed colored darker.
Fig. 2 Sketches of the different CO 2 adsorptions sites for the studied surfaces.The images indicate the top view of (a) d-MoC(001), (b) b-Mo 2 C(001)-C, and (c) b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo surfaces.Sphere coloring is as in Fig. 1.

a
This distance belongs to the CO molecule adsorbed on the b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo surface.b This DQ is for the CO moiety.c This DQ is for the O moiety.
61 eV for b-Mo 2 C(001)-C, this value being sensibly lower than that corresponding to the adsorption on the d-MoC(001) surface.However, the C-C bond distance is still 1.47 Å and the C-O bond lengths are 1.21 and 1.42 Å, as on d-MoC(001), the molecule gets activated, displaying an angle of 1221; the charge on CO 2 indicates that the b-Mo 2 C(001)-C cedes B0.75 electrons, irrespective of including or not the vdW correction.Initially, CO 2 was placed on top of a carbon surface, but during the optimization process displacement of the surface carbon atom bonded to the CO 2 molecule was observed.The final geometry is shown in Fig. 4. Here, the CO 2 molecule is adsorbed

Fig. 3
Fig. 3 Sketches of CO 2 adsorption on d-MoC(001).For (a) MMC site and (b) Top C site.Surfaces are shown by the side view (top) and top view (bottom).Sphere coloring is as in Fig. 1.

Fig. 5
Fig. 5 CO 2 adsorption profile on b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo.Sketches of energy minima and some intermediate steps are shown.
This implies that the CO 2 -CO + O reaction easily occurs on b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo.Fig. 6 compares the growth of the O 1s signal on MoC and b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo after several doses of CO 2 .The data clearly indicate that b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo is much more reactive than MoC, in agreement with the trend seen in the theoretical results reported in Table

Fig. 8
compares the rates for methanol formation on MoC and b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo at 500 and 600 K.At 500 K, the rate for methanol formation on b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo is B7 times larger than the rate on MoC.On the b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo surface, the CO 2 -CO + O reaction occurs spontaneously and the formed CO can be directly hydrogenated to form methanol.On the other hand, the cleavage of one C-O bond of CO 2 on MoC probably requires hydrogenation of the CO 2 molecule to form a HOCO intermediate that eventually decomposes producing a CO molecule which upon reaction with hydrogen forms methanol.

Fig. 6
Fig. 6 Variation of the total O 1s signal after dosing CO 2 to polycrystalline MoC and a b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo surface.In the case of b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo, the adsorbed CO 2 underwent dissociation into O and CO.

Fig. 7
Fig. 7 Uptake of O and CO after several doses of CO 2 to b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo at 300 K.

Fig. 10
Fig. 10 Arrhenius plots for the production of CO and methanol on MoC.In a batch reactor, the metal carbide catalyst was exposed to 0.049 MPa (0.5 atm) of CO 2 and 0.441 MPa (4.5 atm) of H 2 at temperatures of 600, 575, 550, 525, and 500 K.
2 molecule can be activated in all the studied cases.The reactivity of the d-MoC and b-Mo 2 C(001)-C surfaces is similar, sharing a charge transfer surface -CO 2 of B0.75-1 electron, leading to the formation of C-C bonds.The adsorption energy values are at the fringe of chemical interaction, regardless of the covalent C-C bond formation.These surfaces point to a posterior reaction of the activated CO 2 to form suitable products, such as methanol or formic acid via hydrogenation.The adsorption energy values show, however, that CO 2 adsorption is most favorable on b-Mo 2 C(001)-Mo.Here a majority of CO 2 can adopt an activated chemisorbed situation, whereas a fraction of molecules may suffer a spontaneous rupture of a C-O bond leading to the formation of the CO moiety.

Table 1
Results of CO 2 adsorption in molybdenum carbide surfaces