Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:
Title: This is not an instance of (E)
Author: Marques, Teresa
Keywords: Filosofia del llenguatge
Semàntica (Filosofia)
Veritat i mentida
Context (Lingüística)
Negació (Lògica)
Teoria minimalista (Lingüística)
Philosophy of language
Semantics (Philosophy)
Truthfulness and falsehood
Context (Linguistics)
Negation (Logic)
Minimalist theory (Linguistics)
Issue Date: 2018
Publisher: Springer Verlag
Abstract: Semantic paradoxes like the liar are notorious challenges to truth theories. A paradox can be phrased with minimal resources and minimal assumptions. It is not surprising, then, that the liar is also a challenge to minimalism about truth. Horwich (1998/1990) deals swiftly with the paradox, after discriminating between other strategies for avoiding it without compromising minimalism. He dismisses the denial of classical logic, the denial that the concept of truth can coherently be applied to propositions, and the denial that the liar sentence expresses a proposition, but he endorses the denial that the liar is an acceptable instance of the equivalence schema (E). This paper has two main parts. It first shows that Horwich's preferred denial is also problematic. As Simmons (1999), Beall and Armour-Garb (2003), and Asay (2015) argued, the solution is ad hoc, faces a possible loss of expressibility, and is ultimately unstable. Finally, the paper explores a different combination of possibilities for minimalism: treating the truth-predicate as context-dependent, rejecting the notion that the liar expresses a proposition, and reinterpreting negation in some contexts as metalinguistic denial. The paper argues that these are preferable options, but signposts possible dangers ahead.
Note: Versió postprint del document publicat a:
It is part of: Synthese, 2018, vol. 195, num. 3, p. 1035-1063
Related resource:
ISSN: 0039-7857
Appears in Collections:Articles publicats en revistes (Filosofia)

Files in This Item:
File Description SizeFormat 
674220.pdf409.16 kBAdobe PDFView/Open

Items in DSpace are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.