Histological structure of baleen plates and its relevance to sampling for stable isotope studies

Abstract

Stable isotope analysis of baleen plates is a widespread technique for studying baleen whales. Typically, subsamples along the growth axis of the baleen plate are extracted and analysed to examine time-related variation in their stable isotope signals. However, baleen plate tissue is composed of two different tissues: a pair of cortex layers flanking an internal medulla. These two histological components exhibit differential development, and their consolidation as a tissue is therefore likely non-synchronic. This could influence stable isotope results because the stable isotope signal may differ in each subsample according to the proportion of the two histological components extracted from the tissue. In this study, stable isotope analysis was combined with optical microscopy examination of fin whale (Balaenoptera physalus) baleen plates to understand the ontogeny of the two histological components. In both of them, the 15N values followed a sinewave pattern along the growth axis of the baleen plate. However, the 15N values of the cortex appeared to be advanced compared to those of the medulla. Additionally, the amplitude of the 15N values in the oscillations was higher in the cortex than in the medulla. The histological examination revealed that these differences are caused by earlier and faster synthesis of the cortex layer compared to that of the medulla. Because the stable isotope ratios of the two layers differ, we propose that in this type of studies only the outer-most part (closest to the surface) of the cortex should be subsampled and analysed. Additionally, to include the most recently formed tissue, this subsampling should start well below the zwischensubstanz, or baleen 'gum'.