Document type
Master thesisPublication date
Publication license
Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: https://hdl.handle.net/2445/202983
From Searle's Constitutive Rules to the Law
Journal Title
Authors
Director/Tutor
Additional contribution
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Abstract
John R. Searle is the philosopher that introduces the distinction between constitutive rules
and regulative rules for the first time1. He uses them to theorize about philosophy of language and
about social ontology. In this paper, I will try to show the importance of the figure of constitutive
rules to understand some aspects of the legal field. I will propose to focus in two key elements to
understand how to apply Searle's theory to the law, and the advantages and disadvantages that this
application has. I will also introduce some theories of philosophy of law related, and I will connect
them with my proposal.
The paper is organised as follows. In the first section, I will present the two theories where
Searle presents and uses constitutive rules, and their main problems. In the second section, I will
show the general problems of connecting Searle's theory with the legal field, and some theories that
have tried to relate them. In the third section, I will defend that the assignment of a function and the
collective acceptance are the two key elements of Searle's theory that solve most of his problems,
and they allow us to understand how to apply his theory to the legal field. Finally, I will reflect
about the importance that both elements have in the theories previously explored, and about the
general advantages and disadvantages of applying Searle's theory to the law.
Description
Màster en Filosofia Analítica (APhil), Facultat Filosofía, Universitat de Barcelona, Curs: 2017-2018, Director/Tutor: Genoveva Martí i Lorena Ramírez Ludeña
Related resource
Subject (English)
Citation
Collections
Citation
LOJO CARIDE, Alba. From Searle's Constitutive Rules to the Law. [consulted: 16 of October of 2026]. Available at: https://hdl.handle.net/2445/202983