Amb motiu del tancament d'estiu, la validació de documents es reprendrà a partir del 28 d'agost de 2026. Disculpeu les molèsties.
Con motivo del cierre de verano, la validación de documentos se reanudará a partir del 28 de agosto de 2026. Disculpad las molestias
Due to the summer closure, document validation will resume starting August 28, 2026. We apologize for any inconvenience.

Files

685493.pdf (307.39 KB)

Document type

Article

Version

Accepted version

Publication date

2019-01-01

All rights reserved

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: https://hdl.handle.net/2445/166030

Water has a microstructural essence after all

Journal Title

Authors

Director/Tutor

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Related resource

https://doi.org/10.1007/s13194-018-0236-2

Abstract

In recent years attacks on the Kripke-Putnam approach to natural kinds and natural kind terms have proliferated. In a recent paper, Häggqvist and Wikforss (The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 1-23, 2017) attack the once-dominant essentialist account of natural kinds. Häggqvist & Wikforss also suggest that it is time to return to some sort of cluster-based descriptivist semantics for natural kind terms, thus targeting both the metaphysical and semantic tenets that underpin the Kripke-Putnam approach. In our paper we want to challenge both parts of Häggqvist and Wikforss' project. We will argue that the anti-essentialist considerations and arguments they raise against the Kripke-Putnam view are far from compelling in some cases, and certainly not decisive against a reasonable form of the view. On the semantic side, although Häggqvist and Wikforss give few details about what a viable cluster-based descriptivist theory should look like, we will argue that one can already see the approach to be a non-starter. Ignorance and error arguments of the kinds provided by Kripke and Putnam continue to be decisive objections. The only way we can see to save the cluster descriptivist approach is to make the essential properties postulated by Kripke and Putnam become essential features of the descriptive cluster. But this makes the success of the approach parasitic on the correctness of the Kripke-Putnam view.

Subject

Filosofia de la ciència, Categories (Filosofia), Semàntica (Filosofia), Metafísica, Descripció (Filosofia), Referència (Filosofia)

Subject (English)

Philosophy of science, Categories (Philosophy), Semantics (Philosophy), Metaphysics, Description (Philosophy), Reference (Philosophy)

Citation

Collections

Articles publicats en revistes (Filosofia)

Citation

HOEFER, Carl and MARTÍ, Genoveva. Water has a microstructural essence after all. European Journal for Philosophy of Science. 2019. Vol. 9, num. 1. ISSN 1879-4912. [consulted: 12 of August of 2026]. Available at: https://hdl.handle.net/2445/166030

Export metadata

JSON - METS

Share record