Amb motiu del tancament d'estiu, la validació de documents es reprendrà a partir del 28 d'agost de 2026. Disculpeu les molèsties.
Con motivo del cierre de verano, la validación de documentos se reanudará a partir del 28 de agosto de 2026. Disculpad las molestias
Due to the summer closure, document validation will resume starting August 28, 2026. We apologize for any inconvenience.

Files

666554.pdf (558.32 KB)

Document type

Article

Version

Accepted version

Publication date

2017

All rights reserved

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: https://hdl.handle.net/2445/108348

Structural mapping in statistical word problems: A relational reasoning approach to Bayesian inference

Journal Title

Authors

Director/Tutor

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Related resource

https://doi.org/10.3758/s13423-016-1159-6

Abstract

Presenting natural frequencies facilitates Bayesian inferences relative to using percentages. Nevertheless, many people, including highly educated and skilled reasoners, still fail to provide Bayesian responses to these computationally simple problems. We show that the complexity of relational reasoning (e.g., the structural mapping between the presented and requested relations) can help explain the remaining difficulties. With a non-Bayesian inference that required identical arithmetic but afforded a more direct structural mapping, performance was universally high. Furthermore, reducing the relational demands of the task through questions that directed reasoners to use the presented statistics, as compared with questions that prompted the representation of a second, similar sample, also significantly improved reasoning. Distinct error patterns were also observed between these presented- and similar-sample scenarios, which suggested differences in relational-reasoning strategies. On the other hand, while higher numeracy was associated with better Bayesian reasoning, higher-numerate reasoners were not immune to the relational complexity of the task. Together, these findings validate the relational-reasoning view of Bayesian problem solving and highlight the importance of considering not only the presented task structure, but also the complexity of the structural alignment between the presented and requested relations.

Subject

Estadística bayesiana, Raonament (Psicologia)

Subject (English)

Bayesian statistical decision, Reasoning (Psychology)

Citation

Collections

Articles publicats en revistes (Cognició, Desenvolupament i Psicologia de l'Educació)

Citation

JOHNSON, Eric D. and TUBAU SALA, Elisabet. Structural mapping in statistical word problems: A relational reasoning approach to Bayesian inference. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review. 2017. Vol. 24, num. 3, pags. 964-971. ISSN 1069-9384. [consulted: 10 of August of 2026]. Available at: https://hdl.handle.net/2445/108348

Export metadata

JSON - METS

Share record