El CRAI romandrà tancat del 24 de desembre de 2025 al 6 de gener de 2026. La validació de documents es reprendrà a partir del 7 de gener de 2026.
El CRAI permanecerá cerrado del 24 de diciembre de 2025 al 6 de enero de 2026. La validación de documentos se reanudará a partir del 7 de enero de 2026.
From 2025-12-24 to 2026-01-06, the CRAI remain closed and the documents will be validated from 2026-01-07.
 
Miniatura

Fitxers

898475.pdf (410.01 KB)

Tipus de document

Article

Versió

Versió publicada

Data de publicació

2025-12-01

Llicència de publicació

cc by-nc (c) Rosa Gay, María Cristina de la et al., 2025
Si us plau utilitzeu sempre aquest identificador per citar o enllaçar aquest document: https://hdl.handle.net/2445/223043

Improving evaluation of dentistry students in an oral surgery and implantology subject: The PIETA rubric

Títol de la revista

Autors

Director/Tutor

ISSN de la revista

Títol del volum

Recurs relacionat

https://doi.org/10.1111/eje.13121

Resum

Introduction: The objectives were to design an online rubric for fourth-year Dentistry students in the subject of Clinical Oral Surgery and Implantology and to compare the results with the grades of the written exam. Material and methods: A general rubric (PIETA) was designed and started in the academic year 2022-2023, and was tested in 2023-2024. The PIETA rubric evaluated punctuality and interest, assessed with a reflective diary (PI component) and empathy, technique and autonomy (ETA component). Teachers only marked the rubric when a change was perceived, either as improvement or worsening, to avoid repetitive feedback. Final assessment of the clinical work was carried out with the last score of the rubric to enhance student engagement. Evolution of ETA scores at 3 time points (initial, intermediate and final sessions) was analysed with a generalised estimating function (GEE). Rubric scores and written exam grades were correlated with Pearson's correlation. Results: The PIETA rubric was used by 10 clinical assistants to assess 102 students in 2023-2024. The mean number of procedures evaluated was 77.3 (standard deviation [SD] = 37.0) per assistant and 7.6 (SD = 2.5) per student. The PI and ETA components showed a significant positive correlation. The ETA score significantly increased from the first to the last session (p < 0.001). While the PI component did not correlate with the written exam grades, the ETA component showed a significant positive correlation with the outcomes of the written exam in both academic years. Conclusions: The PIETA rubric is easy to use, improves transparency, reduces student complaints of unfair evaluation, and provides immediate feedback after clinical practice. The devil is in the details: feedback and frequency of evaluations should be monitored regularly.

Matèries

Odontologia, Educació superior, Extracció dental, Cirurgia oral

Matèries (anglès)

Dentistry, Higher education, Teeth extraction, Oral surgery

Citació

Col·leccions

Articles publicats en revistes (Odontoestomatologia)

Citació

ROSA GAY, María cristina de la, CAMPS FONT, Octavi, SÁNCHEZ TORRES, Alba, BARBOSA DE FIGUEIREDO, Rui pedro, VALMASEDA CASTELLÓN, Eduardo. Improving evaluation of dentistry students in an oral surgery and implantology subject: The PIETA rubric. _European Journal of Dental Education_. 2025. [consulta: 5 de gener de 2026]. ISSN: 1396-5883. [Disponible a: https://hdl.handle.net/2445/223043]

Exportar metadades

JSON - METS

Compartir registre