Document type
ArticleVersion
Published versionPublication date
Publication license
Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: https://hdl.handle.net/2445/206062
La participación de los estudiantes como evaluadores. Un estudio en las titulaciones universitarias de las artes
Journal Title
Director/Tutor
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Related resource
Abstract
[esp] La implantación de la autoevaluación y la evaluación entre iguales entre estudiantes es todavía limitada en los estudios universitarios, y a ello ha contribuido la existencia de dudas acerca de su validez y fiabilidad. Sistemas de evaluación basados en rúbricas pueden favorecer la eliminación de algunos de estos escollos. En este artículo se analiza la influencia de estos entornos de evaluación con el apoyo de rúbricas en el progreso y en los resultados de aprendizaje obtenidos en la elaboración de proyectos por estudiantes de reciente ingreso en Bellas Artes, Conservación Restauración e Historia del Arte. Los resultados mostraron diferencias estadísticamente significativas entre los estudiantes que asumieron la responsabilidad de la evaluación y los que no. Por consiguiente, se infiere un impacto positivo de la utilización de rúbricas pero también que ese impacto se incrementa ostensiblemente cuando su utilización se acompaña de entornos de autoevaluación o evaluación entre iguales.
[eng] The implementation of self-assessment and peer evaluation among students is still limited in university studies, and this has contributed to doubts about their validity and reliability. Evaluation systems based on clear rubrics can favor the elimination of some of these pitfalls. In this paper we analyze the influence of these evaluation environments with the support of rubrics in the progress and learning results obtained in the preparation of projects by students who have recently begun to study Fine Art, Conservation and Restoration, and Art History. The results showed statistically significant differences between the students who took responsibility for the evaluation and those who did not. Consequently, a positive impact of the use of rubrics is inferred, and the fact that this impact is significantly increased when its use is accompanied by self-assessment or peer review.
[eng] The implementation of self-assessment and peer evaluation among students is still limited in university studies, and this has contributed to doubts about their validity and reliability. Evaluation systems based on clear rubrics can favor the elimination of some of these pitfalls. In this paper we analyze the influence of these evaluation environments with the support of rubrics in the progress and learning results obtained in the preparation of projects by students who have recently begun to study Fine Art, Conservation and Restoration, and Art History. The results showed statistically significant differences between the students who took responsibility for the evaluation and those who did not. Consequently, a positive impact of the use of rubrics is inferred, and the fact that this impact is significantly increased when its use is accompanied by self-assessment or peer review.
Subject (English)
Citation
Citation
GREGORI GIRALT, Eva and MENÉNDEZ VARELA, José Luis. La participación de los estudiantes como evaluadores. Un estudio en las titulaciones universitarias de las artes. Perfiles Educativos. 2017. Vol. 39, num. 156, pags. 141-158. ISSN 0185-2698. [consulted: 18 of August of 2026]. Available at: https://hdl.handle.net/2445/206062